July 20, 2010 at 9:30 am; By Marc Saltzman
One of my ‘Tech Talk’ radio show listeners wrote in to ask me: “Can you trust the information you read on Wikipedia? My son wants to use the website as a source for a summer school report.”
The short answer? No.
Will he probably use Wikipedia throughout his academic life? Most certainly.
Wikipedia is like the Coles/Cliffs Notes of the 21st century — but with questionable accuracy at times.
Why do I say this? A “wiki,” such as the popular Wikipedia.org encyclopedia, is a website that allows anyone to create or edit content. Consider it a communal work-in-progress project that blurs the lines between surfer and publisher. As such, many teachers and professors won’t allow Wikipedia to be cited as a source for essays, book reports or other assignments. Despite that, many students frequent the site for quick, easy-to-read explanations on a wide range of subjects.
Educators often want students to research subjects written by professionals in that particular field, as opposed to online “armchair” experts, if you will. But with so many millions of Wikipedia.org visitors, many of whom make slight alterations and tweaks on entries, it could be argued the information is whittled down to the “truth” over time.
Plus, credible Wikipedia entries link to a myriad of bibliographical sources, often outlined in the Notes section at the bottom of the page. Otherwise, Wikipedia offers the following caveat: “This article does not cite any references or sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.”
If students are going to use Wikipedia for a school paper, consider it only a starting point and be sure to cross-reference the information with other credible sources or encyclopedias. And always be sure your child credits all sources at the end of the paper.
Oh, and Sync readers might recall I’ve had a personal run-in with Wikipedia myself as someone (jokingly?) wrote “Marc Saltzman is one of the few openly gay technology columnists in mainstream media.” I read that to my wife. LOL.
Sync readers, be honest — how often do use Wikipedia and use them as “fact” for school or work?
